* · Articles

Considering Ordination Part 2

People seem to have a vast array of projections about monks and nuns. For Westerners these are largely carry-overs from their image of Christian monastics and other clergy. We also seem to take references from Hollywood’s vision of peaceful Zen monasteries or even the Shaolin monks in our projection of what monasticism means. This is not negative, per se; it is just how the conceptual mind works. We take bits and pieces from our experience and imagination and we solidify them into a conceptual projection. The tension comes in when we try to fit mundane appearances into the shape of our projections– the way things are vs. the way things should be.

Often as not monks and nuns in the West are isolated as the single ordained person in a community of lay people. For the monastic himself or herself, a great deal of guidance can be taken from the Vinaya (the monastic code) as per what is appropriate. Traditionally, lay people do not study the Vinaya, and it certainly is not expected for lay people to have a comprehensive understanding of the monastic vows and rituals. In fact, too much awareness of these things can lead lay people to criticize the ordained for not behaving ‘correctly’. On the other hand, difficulties arise when lay people have no recompense other than popular culture and Christianity in forming their understanding of Buddhist monks and nuns. It is neither comfortable nor desirable for Westerners to act Asian in a desire to be ‘correct’ as monastics. This may work if the Western monk or nun is in training in Asia, but in the West it does not lead to a style of monasticism feasible for Westerners. We need to discern what is Vinaya, and what is merely a reflection of its host culture. I think much can learned from Christian monasticism, but we also need to be aware of the differences between our two traditions. For example, most Christian monks and nuns are trained prior to taking lifelong ordination. In the Buddhist tradition ordination is often the very first step in training. This leads to difficulties when one gets ordained by a travelling lama. Who trains the new monastic? It is also confusing for some lay people who expect that the ordained person has been ordained on the basis of qualifications.

I think these issues are very much worthy of consideration, especially to prospective monastics. The Buddha taught that there is no permanent, truly established identity. Thus, we need have mindfulness when it comes to pursuing a ‘monastic identity’. Since my last post I have given this a great deal of thought. Why do people desire so deeply to be ordained? Why do they later disrobe? I think it sometimes has to do with grasping after identity. Identity grasping, after all, is the linchpin of samsara. Learning to identify and deconstruct identity grasping is an extremely significant part of the Buddhist path.

How, then, should we approach monasticism? I think we must see it as a practice, and we must view monastics as people doing a special kind of practice. The Vinaya itself is not merely a set of rules for the ordained; it is a description of the practice of monasticism. We don’t choose to abandon sexual conduct etc. because we aren’t interested in it. We abandon it because we see it as harmful. Why is it harmful? Because it increases desire and thus binds us more tightly to cyclic existence. All of the monastic vows have to do with abandoning actions harmful to oneself and others as well as creating a situation were mental virtues may naturally increase. So instead of ordination because ‘this is who I want to be’, I suggest ordination because ‘this is how I want to practice in order to attain enlightenment’.


2 thoughts on “Considering Ordination Part 2

  1. Amen Sister! As I’ve said before, I think one of the major reasons for Westerners disrobing is that there is no follow-up from the lamas after ordination, even if they are around. I just don’t think they’re that interested in establishing monasticism in the West. However, there are higher expectations from the lamas and the lay people for us, but no way to meet those expectations. We get criticism from both sides. Six months after I was ordained, a lay person at the center I was associated with asked me about some detail on the altar, but I couldn’t explain it. Another lay woman looked at me with half suprise and half disgust and said, “You’re ordained and you don’t know that?” On another occasion, a visiting lama (one not regulary in the West) kept asking the ordained to do this or that–assist in rituals and whatnot. I kept saying, “Sorry, but I don’t know how to do that,” so he finally asked me how long I’d been ordained. When I told him (it had been two or three years at the time) he was clearly surprised…and dissapointed. I would say half of the ordained in the Tibetan tradition that I’ve known have quit. I thought about it, but came to Korea instead.So I’m really glad you’re getting an education in India. When you’ve completed your studies, I’m sure your going to rock the boat in a system that keeps Western ordained on the fringes.

  2. I think people have these reactions because they dont trully understand why you are ordained. Most lay people and even lamas often confuse tradition with real purpose. Dont let them get to you, stay strong! I life far far away from any Buddhist temple, any buddhists at all. Even though i study every day i wish there were more buddhists around here to talk to. I know its not something for everybody and i imagine monastic life is even a tougher challenge. This is why we have to persevere and keep going!PS: Do monks get to travel? It would be so nice to see some in Europe!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s